We Still Don’t Trust You

Earlier in their careers, Future and Metro Boomin always sounded committed to bringing the best and the weirdest out of each other. The menace in the pits of Metro’s beats matched Future’s drug tales and bouts of dead-eyed hedonism, and darker, stranger variants on that chemistry kept things exciting. Whether it’s the seething snap of an “I Serve the Base,” the creaking minimalism of a “My Collection,” or the fidgety pomp of a “Jumpman,” the duo always pushed the boundaries of mainstream trap in seedier directions.

And that was the biggest issue with their first official collaborative album We Don’t Trust You. They still crafted a few mean sleeper hits, but outside of the rich-guy rapper beef simmering in between the lines, their edges had dulled. For all the buildup, too many of those songs took the Capital-R Rap Album prompt too seriously, rehashing old ideas in grander, blander ways. The double-disc sequel album, We Still Don’t Trust You, is a more encouraging heel turn. Future and Metro sharpen some of that bite by bringing their ears to a brighter, slightly sappier space.

It’s still familiar ground for both of them. Future, in particular, is back in the emotional headspace that fueled so much of HNDRXX, swirling between flexing from his throne and lovesick come-ons. He still relishes playing the villain on occasion—“One Big Family” is about juggling upwards of 20 women at a time, three of whom share the same name—but there’s just as much tear-soaked reflection over exes and post-coital shopping sprees. On the neon-bright “Drink N Dance,” he croons about racing Maybachs and throwing lavish sex parties in Abu Dhabi like he just found a rare foil Pokemon card. Later, on “Mile High Memories,” he’s looking for silver linings in a lover who might be doing him dirty, belting “You can fuck on him as long as you thinkin’ ‘bout me,” trying and failing to sound above it all. It isn’t often that Future gets the short end of the stick, and hearing him jump between player and patsy, sometimes in the same song, remains electrifying.

For Metro’s part, he’s actually found a way to turn the Achilles’ heel of his post-COVID output—production that sounds too polished and anonymous—into a strength. The title track veers toward synth-pop that wouldn’t sound out of place on The Weeknd’s Dawn FM, complete with Abel mocking his old label OVO in falsetto (“They shooters making TikToks!”). Several songs dip into various shades of R&B, from the new-age Isley Brothers smoothness of “All to Myself” to “Gracious,” which sounds like a stripped-back version of the kind of plugg&b that Summrs or Highway would drool over.

Don’t get it twisted: Metro still has plenty of the brooding maximalist thumpers that powered both 2022’s Heroes & Villains and Metro’s soundtrack to Spider-Man: Across The Spiderverse, but it’s a bit looser, more willing to explore and have fun slightly removed from Metro and Future’s comfort zones. At the very least, none of it sounds as forced or unnecessary as when he conducted an actual orchestra through some of his greatest hits.

It’s also nearly 30 minutes longer than the already overstuffed original, which makes the slow sections drag even more. Future and Metro shine brightest when they’re shrugging their way through the prettiest or nastiest music you’ve ever heard, but a handful of songs are just lethargic, existing solely to spin their designer wheels. Cuts on the 18-track first disc like “This Sunday” and “Came to the Party” overcome generic beats because Future sells his jet-setting and chauvinism just well enough to earn a chuckle or two (I laughed at Diddy’s name being audibly omitted from a joke about The Notorious B.I.G. on the former). But the seven songs that make up the second disc mostly pale in comparison, back to the self-serious recycling of the first album.

We Still Don’t Trust You is in an odd position compared to We Don’t Trust You, and that may or may not be by design. Kendrick Lamar turned the heat up on a decade-long rap cold war with Drake during his appearance on “Like That,” and a handful of the album’s main and guest verses were fueled by that roiling sense of animosity, even if it boils down to a bunch of rich musicians jabbing at each other for sport. But outside of a handful of snippy soundbites from The Weeknd and A$AP Rocky and a candid verse from feature-killer-turned-beef-dodger J. Cole, the feud isn’t the binding agent it previously was. Instead of trying to manufacture a viral moment within a long-awaited collab from two icons of 2010s rap, the tenuous trust in We Still Don’t Trust You is aimed mostly at the lovers instead of the fighters. It settles for being a mildly adventurous AAA rap album made by two friends searching for fun in heartbreak.