Jeff Weiss’ Washington Post article detailing the inaugural Posty Fest isn’t a conventional stinkpiece a lot because it as an unwavering Comedy Central roast. “What Post Malone is promoting is the chill-bro relatability of the third-most-sensitive member of a frat home, softly crooning acoustic guitar rap covers to seduce Gammas after a pledge paddling. He is the dynamite hack — the platonic playlist substitute on the Duke University espresso store so the vp doesn’t hearth you for taking part in Young Dolph.”
While the biting scorching take was promptly lambasted throughout the web as a snobbish try at satire, with Post responding quite curtly Twitter, it accommodates one plain fact: America has fallen head over heels for the “rhinestone cowboy who seems like he crawled out of a primordial swamp of nacho cheese.” Critics have lengthy complained concerning the lack of substance in pop music, issuing prolonged diatribes that vary from sensationalistic narcissism to pretentious finger-pointing. When it involves Post Malone, they’re not often complimentary. Purposefully inflammatory items from each side of the aisle gas the raging fires of hypocrisy to the purpose the place it’s unimaginable to search out a solution that may fulfill everybody. And trying to appease all events concerned, because it seems, can have the exact opposite impact.
Frazer Harrison/Getty Images
Austin Richard Post, the suburban-Dallas-raised rapper who was named by Nielsen as 2018’s hottest musician, is certainly not a revolutionary, however he’s a harbinger of the instances. He’s a descendant of the melodic drift that set sail the day Kanye’s 808s & Heartbreak blueprint was launched to the plenty. Dubbed by Weiss because the “avatar of algorithm tradition,” Post boasts music that’s moored in sentient lethargy and watered down understandings of heartbreak, loneliness, and self-pity. His quirky and sometimes endearing sing-song tunes are designed for Get Turnt and Sad Boy Hours playlists alike.
Nonetheless, the 23-year-old has needed to develop a thick pores and skin ever since he reached mainstream consideration in 2015. He’s been known as a glorified nation star, artistically problematic, impulsive and short-sighted, talentless, outright deaf to the “narratives of possession that course by means of hip-hop,” and nearly each different insult conceivable. Some critics have expressed extra complete issues, with radio character Charlamagne Tha God condemning Post as the subsequent “Great White Hype” and citing Iggy Azalea and Macklemore as earlier examples of white rappers who’ve discovered large business success.
To say that Post’s music is en vogue can be a laughable understatement. The Ringer workers author Lindsay Zoladz put it merely: “he’s so standard proper now that you would be able to’t ignore him.” Last April, the aspiring style lane-changer’s Beerbongs & Bentleys debuted at No. 1, shattering streaming data the identical candy-coated system of earlier efforts. Post’s Twitter proclamation that he wished to take hip-hop and “stretch it to date that individuals who could not hearken to it, hearken to it” proved to be wildly prophetic, together with his sophomore outing touchdown because the second most-streamed album within the U.S. on Spotify in 2018. Perhaps much more spectacular is that Stoney, his two-year-old debut, someway managed to carry on at No. 5, a statistic that speaks volumes by itself.
Post comes off as a honest and likable goofball in all of the interviews that he’s been part of, whether or not it’s crushing scorching wings with Sean Evans, going undercover with GQ, or casually chatting with Ethan and Hila Klein of H3H3. A number of the hate that he endures is superficial: he seems just like the Pig-Pen equal of a fuel station clerk who would fortunately provide to share the California rolls that he bought at an worker low cost value. He appears nicely conscious of this unlucky “even my shadow reeks of cigarettes” characterization: “On Halloween, they got here dressed up like me, which is straightforward: Just look homeless.” Over the previous 12 months or so, he has undergone a quasi-Queer Eye makeover, abandoning the “White Iverson” cornrows for a stringy man-bun earlier than most lately deciding on a musty mess of curls after claims surfaced of him smelling so dangerous that it induced vomiting amongst those that met him. His limited-edition collaboration with foam clog firm Crocs (which offered out in mere minutes) is a testomony to his oddball, “cowboy shit” tendencies and 21-century standing as a dwelling and respiration music-meme hybrid.
For these whose objections run a lot deeper, Post stands an embarrassing embodiment of every little thing “unsuitable” with hip-hop, an business plant embalmed in day-old Bud Light and zapped again to life to roam unchecked throughout the music charts for the amusement of unsavory white rap followers. These accusations have been fueled partially by incidents comparable to an apology-inducing 2015 video of pre-fame Post utilizing the N-word, a rambling response to a query concerning the Black Lives Matter motion throughout an interview with The Breakfast Club, and his dismissal from XXL’s annual Freshman cowl in 2016 resulting from experiences that he was “going in additional of a rock/pop/nation course.”
He’s made quite a few makes an attempt to distance himself from the “rapper” title in favor of the extra nebulous “musician,” a transfer that’s perceived by critics as ignorantly dismissive because of the means that it caters to white artists. His struggles to wrestle with questions of race and what it means to be black in America have elicited cries of white fragility and privilege. “If you are in search of lyrics, should you’re seeking to cry, should you’re trying to consider life, do not hearken to hip-hop,” Post informed Polish information outlet NewOnce in 2017. He later handed off his provocative feedback as being the results of a beer-tasting session that occurred through the interview (NewOnce denied these claims).
And but, the pop savant has been handsomely rewarded for his efforts. It’s a weird conundrum: are listeners to consider Post’s assertion that “style is silly,” and that there’s no contradiction in him singing with Justin Bieber one second and 21 Savage the subsequent? Or is he not appropriately exercising due diligence in partaking in a predominantly black artform?
Frazer Harrison/Getty Images
There exists a perceptible gray space between musical inclination and self-perception that leaves loads of room for criticism, though Post’s diehard followers appear wholly unbothered by such issues. In truth, his curated “outlaw” renown has solely made him extra standard. “Post is just like the Donald Trump of hip-hop,” bragged Rob Stevenson, an govt at Malone’s label, Republic Records. “Things that ought to’ve killed his profession have solely made him larger.”
Post’s need to reinvent himself, to attain creative anonymity with out penalties, is the foundation reason behind this controversy. The empty signifiers, or quite “empty energy,” of his complete musical existence are satirically each the rationale for his huge success and the rationale for his perceived “tradition vulture” inferiority. He’s a product of the present local weather during which music that’s instinctively accessible trumps all. Sonic aesthetic is more and more prized by a mainstream consumer-base that enjoys music as a passive exercise, one thing to be thrown on within the background and forgotten till later discover (or till Spotify updates its Rap Car playlist). Palatable, pop-friendly lure traits are what’s in, and Post has continued to mine this jackpot with a sound that’s undemanding and mind-numbingly catchy.
For higher or worse (relying in your view), he’s a part of the brand new wave of “rappers” blurring the sides of hip-hop and increasing its boundaries. Emo, rap, and people now not operate as distinct containers to be checked in a drop-down menu. Instead, they’re now components to be blended each which means. It’s a specific form of musical experimentation that’s troublesome to tug off in convincing vogue, however Post stays undeterred in his quest to create “bops for on a regular basis use.” And his present second of pop ubiquity as a sequined “redneck nation insurgent” has proven no indicators of letting up anytime quickly.
Post Malone’s endurance was cranked as much as absolutely the max in 2018, as evidenced by his streaming monopoly. It’s true that numbers don’t lie, however one can’t assist however marvel if he’s constructed for the lengthy haul, or if it’s a forgone conclusion that his expiration date is simply over the horizon. “I do know it piss you off to see me winnin’,” he confidently warbles on new single “Wow.” It’s his newest entry in a listing that features loads of thematically cheesing odes to the “haters.” Admittedly, Post appears to be superb with the enormous goal on his again. While it’s potential that there shall be future missteps and extra cringeworthy, off-color remarks, his rising legion of supporters will proceed to drown out the incredulous outbursts from critics. Whether or not you consider that he’s exploiting modernity’s most bankable music type by churning out “one of many shallowest bastardizations of rap so far,” his enchantment stays as sturdy as ever, a lot to the chagrin of business gatekeepers.